Old & Co.

How to Sell Your Antiques: Auction, Dealer, or Online?

Old & Co. Editorial7 min read29 March 2026

Navigating the modern antiques market needn't be daunting, whether you're selling a treasured heirloom or an unexpected attic discovery, specialist dealers, auction houses, and online platforms each offer distinct advantages depending on your item's value and urgency. Our expert analysis breaks down the three main sales routes to help you maximise returns and find the right buyers for your pieces.

You've discovered something interesting in your attic. Perhaps it's a piece of Staffordshire pottery, a signed piece of Arts and Crafts furniture, or even a collection of Victorian silver spoons. Your heart races with possibility, and you wonder: what's it worth, and more importantly, how do you actually sell it? The antiques market has evolved dramatically over the past decade, offering sellers multiple pathways to reach buyers. Each route has distinct advantages, drawbacks, and suitability depending on your item's value, condition, and your personal circumstances. Understanding these three primary channels, traditional auction houses, specialist dealers, and online platforms, will empower you to make an informed decision that maximises your return.

Understanding the Three Main Sales Channels

The antiques market operates through three distinctly different ecosystems, each with its own buyer base, pricing structure, and logistical requirements. Recognising these differences is your first step towards choosing wisely. Some sellers benefit from the prestige of a prestigious auction house, whilst others find their niche through trusted local dealers or the immediacy of online sales. The "best" option isn't universal, it depends entirely on your specific item and circumstances.

Auction Houses: The Premium Route for Quality Pieces

Auction houses ranging from Sotheby's and Christie's to regional specialists represent the traditional pathway for significant antiques. These venues excel at marketing items to serious collectors worldwide and establishing provenance through expert analysis and cataloguing.

For items valued above £500, particularly those with interesting histories or exceptional craftsmanship, auctions offer compelling advantages. A piece of Meissen porcelain, for instance, might achieve substantially more at auction through competitive bidding than through any other channel. Similarly, signed Arts and Crafts pieces by makers like Gustav Stickley have achieved remarkable results at specialist auctions, a Morris chair in original condition recently fetched over £3,500 at regional auction, significantly exceeding its pre-sale estimate.

The process begins with a free valuation appointment, where a specialist assesses your item's authenticity, age, condition, and market potential. Cross-referenced against auction records and comparable sales, these assessments are typically reliable indicators of likely outcomes. Many auction houses charge no upfront fees for this service.

Understanding auction house costs is crucial. Commission structures typically range from fifteen to twenty-five percent of the hammer price, plus VAT. Buyers also pay a premium, usually ten to fifteen percent. Some houses charge modest insurance and handling fees. For a £1,000 item, expect to net approximately £750 after all deductions.

Auction houses shine when handling decorative arts, fine furniture, jewellery, and specialist collections. They're particularly effective for items with provenance, documentation of ownership history strengthens both authentication and market appeal. A Victorian brooch with jeweller's hallmarks or a piece of Minton pottery bearing the factory mark will command stronger prices through auction.

However, auctions aren't without drawbacks. The process typically requires six to eight weeks from valuation to sale, with no guarantee of reaching reserve price. Lower-value items might not justify the commission structure. Additionally, hammer prices at auction don't necessarily equate to what you'll receive, the buyer's premium goes to the auction house, not the seller.

Specialist Dealers: The Relationship Approach

Antique dealers form the backbone of the retail market, operating through individual shops, market stalls, and increasingly, online showrooms. Working with a dealer involves a different dynamic: they're purchasing your item for resale, so they'll typically offer below estimated retail value, their profit margin depends on the difference between purchase price and selling price.

The dealer route works exceptionally well for sellers seeking speed, simplicity, and certainty. When you sell to a dealer, payment is immediate, collection is usually arranged, and you avoid commission structures entirely. This matters significantly if you're downsizing quickly, need funds immediately, or prefer a straightforward transaction.

Dealer pricing typically ranges from forty to sixty percent of retail value, depending on how readily the item sells within their customer base. A piece of Staffordshire pottery might command sixty percent of retail through a dealer who specialises in ceramics, but substantially less through a generalist shop. This is where specialist assessment proves invaluable, dealers with deep knowledge of specific categories make better buying offers because they understand market demand precisely.

The relationship approach also offers advantages beyond valuation. Experienced dealers often identify issues invisible to untrained eyes, a repaired section of porcelain, alterations to furniture, or replaced components that reduce value. Their honest assessment, whilst sometimes disappointing, prevents regrettable mistakes.

Finding the right dealer requires effort. Rather than offering items to the first shop encountered, contact three or four specialists in your item's category. Dealers recognising genuine quality will make competitive offers when they see authentic pieces. A Georgian silver spoon with clear hallmarks might attract substantially different offers depending on the dealer's customer base and specialisation.

Online Platforms: The Democratic Marketplace

Online selling has democratised the antiques market, enabling individuals to reach global audiences without intermediaries. Specialist platforms like Catawiki and 1stDibs combine authentication services with expert marketing, whilst general marketplaces including eBay and Facebook Marketplace offer accessibility with minimal gatekeeping.

This channel suits items valued between £50 and £500, where auction commissions prove disproportionate and dealer margins seem excessive. Online selling also works exceptionally well for collections, a set of twelve Victorian teacups, for instance, might sell faster and at better prices online than through traditional channels, as enthusiasts searching specifically for matching sets can find them easily.

The online route demands effort. Successful selling requires quality photography, accurate descriptions, honest disclosure of condition issues, and realistic pricing informed by researching comparable listings. Successful sellers take multiple images from different angles, highlight maker's marks clearly, and provide measurements.

Commission structures vary significantly. eBay charges insertion fees plus thirteen percent final value fees. Specialist platforms often charge fifteen to twenty percent. Payment security typically involves escrow services holding funds until buyers confirm satisfaction, protecting both parties.

Shipping costs and logistics represent the primary online challenge. Fragile items require professional packing, a substantial antique bowl might cost £40 to pack and ship, reducing profit margins considerably. Some sellers misjudge this element and find their apparent profit vanishing into logistics costs.

Making Your Decision: A Practical Framework

Consider four factors when choosing your sales channel:

Item value: Above £1,000, auction houses make sense. Between £100-£1,000, evaluate whether commissions justify the approach. Below £100, online selling typically offers better returns than dealer purchase offers.

Time sensitivity: Need funds immediately? Dealers provide certainty and speed. Can you wait six weeks? Auctions might return more. Want flexibility? Online offers options.

Item type: Specialist categories perform better at auction. General decorative items suit dealers. Common items with specific enthusiast groups thrive online.

Condition and provenance: Museum-quality pieces with documentation suit auctions. Good condition pieces suit dealers. Honest sales with disclosed condition issues suit online platforms.

Conclusion

Selling antiques successfully requires matching your item to the most suitable marketplace. Auction houses suit significant pieces with collector appeal and documented provenance. Specialist dealers offer speed and certainty for items they genuinely want. Online platforms provide access to international audiences for items with defined buyer groups. Rather than viewing these channels as competitors, experienced sellers often use all three strategically, depending on specific circumstances. Whatever route you choose, invest time in proper valuation, condition assessment, and accurate representation. These fundamentals, more than the selling channel itself, determine whether you realise truly satisfying returns from your antiques.

  • selling
  • auction
  • dealer

Your bag